True COGS vs Stockie for weighted average cost in Shopify
Both keep a moving weighted average cost and can write it to Shopify's Cost per item. The difference is where stock has to be received. Stockie updates its average only when a purchase order is received in Stockie; its help centre says stock received against a Shopify purchase order, a transfer or a manual adjustment adds quantity without cost. True COGS works from Shopify's own purchase orders and transfers, so you keep receiving in Shopify, and it averages each price with the units already on hand. Stockie includes weighted average on its Pro Plus plan ($59.99 a month) inside a full inventory system with forecasting, stocktakes and barcode receiving. True COGS includes it on every plan, free for up to 25 variants, with FIFO, freight and duty and a month-end close from $29 a month.
Feature by feature
| True COGS | Stockie | |
|---|---|---|
| Main job | Inventory costing: the cost of every delivery, a dated cost history, stock value and a month-end close | Inventory management: forecasting, purchase orders, stocktakes, alerts and barcode receiving, with landed and average costs |
| Where stock must be received for the average | In Shopify: its purchase orders and transfers (and receipts from Inventory Planner) | In Stockie: its help centre says to receive every purchase order in Stockie |
| Stock that arrives another way | Listed on the Waiting page for its price | Adds quantity without cost, so the average drifts (Stockie help centre) |
| How the average is worked out | (units on hand × current average + units received × price paid) ÷ (units on hand + units received) | A running weighted average built from the landed cost of each purchase order received; the formula is not published |
| Weighted average cost | Every plan, including Free (up to 25 variants) | Pro Plus plan |
| FIFO cost | Paid plans | Not described in its average-cost help pages |
| Freight and duty in the unit cost | Paid plans, split across the delivery | Yes: shipping, duties, freight, insurance and fees added to the order |
| Writes Shopify's Cost per item | Yes, on each receipt | Yes, with cost sync set to Average cost (automatic or manual) |
| Dated cost history | Yes: every price paid, with its date, kept | Not described in the help pages read |
| Month-end close | Paid plans; COGS entry to QuickBooks Online | Not described |
| Forecasting, reorder points, stocktakes, barcodes | No | Yes |
| Lowest plan with weighted average | Free; paid plans from $29/month | $59.99/month, 14-day free trial |
| Rating on 12 November 2026 | 5.0 (5 reviews) | 4.9 (184 reviews), Built for Shopify |
Why where you receive decides the average
A weighted average is only right if every delivery brings its price with it. Shopify itself keeps Cost per item fixed when stock arrives, so whichever app keeps the average has to see each delivery and its price.
Since Stocky closed on 31 August 2026, Shopify's own path is to create and receive purchase orders in the Shopify admin (Shopify Help). If you follow that path, an app that reads Shopify's purchase orders and transfers keeps your average right without changing how your team receives. If you move receiving into Stockie, its average sees every delivery received there, and Stockie asks you to finish migrating before you switch average cost on.
A worked example with True COGS: 100 units on hand at $10.00, and a purchase order of 50 arrives at $12.40. (100 × $10.00 + 50 × $12.40) ÷ 150 = $10.80, written to Cost per item when the order is received. The last price, $12.40, is not applied to all 150 units.
Which fits which store
- You want one app to forecast, order, receive with barcodes, count stock and cost it: Stockie, on Pro Plus, with receiving moved into Stockie.
- You receive with Shopify's own purchase orders or transfers and want the cost right: True COGS, free to start, with FIFO, freight and duty and a month-end close on paid plans.
- Your purchase orders live in Inventory Planner: True COGS reads received Inventory Planner purchase orders and records exact matches at their price.
- Your accountant needs month-end COGS and stock value: True COGS closes each month on paid plans and can post the COGS entry to QuickBooks Online.
See also: Shopify COGS apps compared · Does Shopify calculate weighted average cost? · True COGS vs Cogsy.
Questions merchants ask
Does Stockie calculate weighted average cost?
Yes, on its Pro Plus plan ($59.99 a month). Its help centre describes a running weighted average built from the landed cost of every purchase order received in Stockie, which it can sync to Shopify's Cost per item.
Does Stockie's average cost work with Shopify's own purchase orders?
Not for cost. Stockie's help centre says to receive every purchase order in Stockie; stock received against a Shopify purchase order, a transfer or a manual adjustment adds quantity without cost, so the average drifts from what you paid.
Does True COGS work with Shopify's own purchase orders?
Yes. True COGS records the price on each Shopify purchase order or transfer when it is received, averages it with the units already on hand, and writes the result to Cost per item.
Which one is cheaper for weighted average cost?
True COGS includes weighted average on every plan: free for up to 25 variants with a cost on record, then $29, $49 or $79 a month. Stockie includes it on Pro Plus at $59.99 a month, with a 14-day free trial, alongside forecasting, purchase orders and stocktakes.
Which one does FIFO?
True COGS does FIFO on paid plans. Stockie's help pages on average cost do not describe FIFO.
Can I use True COGS and Stockie together?
Yes, if only one of them writes Shopify's Cost per item. If both write it, they overwrite each other.
Try True COGS free. True COGS is an inventory costing app for Shopify by Nexus Logic Systems. It records the price you paid on every delivery (a received purchase order or a transfer), with its share of freight and duty on paid plans, keeps every price with its date, and writes your moving weighted average cost, or FIFO cost on a paid plan, to Shopify's Cost per item. It is free for up to 25 variants with a cost on record; paid plans start at $29 a month or $290 a year.
Install from the App StoreSources
- Stockie on the Shopify App Store (plans and rating, read 12 November 2026)
- Stockie Help: Average cost tracking (updated 11 September 2026)
- Stockie Help: Once average costs are on, receive in Stockie (updated 20 August 2026)
- Stockie Help: Syncing costs with Shopify (updated 20 August 2026)
- True COGS on the Shopify App Store
- True COGS user guide
- Shopify Help: Migrating from Stocky to Shopify inventory management